Councilman's Corner: Land Use and Business Expansion

San Carlos Councilman Mark Olbert chimes in on the upcoming Carlos Club decision.


Disclaimer: The opinions and perspectives in Mark's article are his own, and do not represent the official position of the City of San Carlos or its City Council.

You may have wondered why I haven’t written about the Council’s upcoming review of the Carlos Club expansion application. There’s a simple reason: I haven’t made up my mind.

And it’s important that I not make up my mind before the public hearing, because the Council acts in a quasi-judicial role on these kinds of matters. For the duration of the hearing the five of us will be acting as judges, and judges need to base their decisions on the law and the material presented to them “at trial”. Sadly, we don’t get to wear robes while acting in this capacity .

But there is one clarification of the ongoing public dialog that I want to make before Monday.

Most of the press coverage, and most of the discussions among residents that I’ve seen or heard, have characterized the review as a decision on whether or not the Carlos Club will be allowed to expand. That’s not what the Council will be deciding on Monday.

We will be reviewing a proposed land use change, not a business expansion proposal. It’s easy to confuse the two, because it’s unlikely Fred Duncan, the owner of the Carlos Club, would opt to expand his business without being granted the land use change. But he could. Or he could opt to not expand even if the change is approved. Changing how the land can be used, and actually using it for that new purpose, are two separate and distinct issues.

This may sound like a minor or semantic distinction. But it’s not.

A land use change is the grant of a property right, which can be exercised or enjoyed by any owner of the property. Land use changes aren’t granted to a specific person or business — they “run with the land“. And, like any property right, governmental action to modify them in any way so as to reduce their value is considered a “taking”, requiring compensation of whoever owns the property when the taking occurs. Contrary to popular belief, it’s quite rare for a public agency to take a property right away, or even reduce its value. It’s costly, both financially and politically, and can damage a community’s reputation.

So granting a new property right is a serious matter. That’s even more true when granting it may involve public health and safety.

--Mark Olbert

Thomas Knudsen April 07, 2012 at 04:24 PM
There is more to this vote than simply granting a single parcel owner an exception to existing land use policy. Other potential candidates with similar land-use requests would have an easier time making a case for their own variances and CUPs. 2 years ago we convened GPAC to establish land use guidelines for all of San San Carlos. These plans were heavily scrutinized by the public and the Planning Commission. Last year the zoning ordinance was scrutinized by Planning, EDAC, and City Council before adoption. This was a monumental task, and granted, some small errors undoubtedly slipped through the cracks. If Council decides this is one of those things, then let's change the ordinance to make it right, so ALL similar parcels are on equal footing. I say this without prejudice as to which way I feel Council should vote. I can see outdoor-entertainment policy as being both good for a vibrant downtown, and bad for the neighboring community. My point is this- good planning code has an element of fairness, and is what we all implicitly agree to when we purchase land in a municipality. Exceptions should be granted ONLY under extraordinary circumstances, where the parcel owner can demonstrate undue hardship. If Council feels that the existing ordinance is too restrictive, then It should be amended to explicitly allow such uses for all similar parcels.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »